Skip to content

Open late: 10am to 10pm Mon–Thu, 10am to midnight Fri–Sun

Region and language USDEN
Region and language

Country/region and currency

0 items in cart

Cart

Your cart is empty.

Blue Jay's Cauldron

The melting pot of all things nerd

Singles, sealed boxes, minis, paints and comics, stirred together by fellow players. Find the card you need, then stay for game night or grab a comic & a comfy seat to vibe with us! ^.^

Blue Jay's Cauldron

Thank you for your service

All military (including their families) and first responders get 25% off their orders (limit 1 use per order) as a thank you for your service ^.^

Verify with GOVX ID

Pick your potion

Every format, every fandom, one cauldron. Step through a portal.

Browse everything

Fresh from the cauldron

Magic singles for every format, from Commander staples to Vintage oddities.

View all
  • Burst Lightning (Extended Art)

    Burst Lightning (Extended Art) [SSP - 4]

    Price: $15.70
  • Island (0513) (First-Place Foil)

    Island (0513) (First-Place Foil) [DFT - 513]

    Price: $8.61
  • Codsworth, Handy Helper

    Codsworth, Handy Helper [PIP - 14]

    Price: $16.43
  • Breeches, Brazen Plunderer (Borderless)

    Breeches, Brazen Plunderer (Borderless) [SPG - 6]

    Price: $5.53
  • Sarkhan's Triumph

    Sarkhan's Triumph [DTK - 154]

    Price: $4.63
  • Pest Control

    Pest Control [PPFRA - 22]

    Price: $3.36
  • Jadar, Ghoulcaller of Nephalia

    Jadar, Ghoulcaller of Nephalia [PPMID - 108]

    Price: $2.31
  • Sab-Sunen, Luxa Embodied

    Sab-Sunen, Luxa Embodied [PPDFT - 221]

    Price: $2.39
  • Pensive Professor

    Pensive Professor [PPSOS - 63]

    Price: $0.92
  • Mesmeric Fiend

    Mesmeric Fiend [LIST - 69/143]

    Price: $1.35

Pull up a chair, the cauldron is warm

Trade, play and paint with the regulars. We stay open late, and our Discord is where the next game night gets planned.

Store hours

Monday – Thursday: 10am to 10pm

Friday – Sunday: 10am to midnight

Powered by Manage Comics

Subscribe to your favorite series

Never miss an issue. Set up your pull list and we’ll hold every new release for you.

Manage my comics

Gotta sleeve ’em all

Pokémon singles for your binder, your deck or your next trade.

View all
  • Pikachu - 029/128

    Pikachu - 029/128 [30C]

    Price: $0.49
  • Pikachu - 025/128

    Pikachu - 025/128 [30C]

    Price: $0.40
  • Zeraora VSTAR

    Zeraora VSTAR [CRZ:GG - GG43/GG70]

    Price: $18.80
  • Cynthia's Garchomp ex

    Cynthia's Garchomp ex [SVP - 204]

    Price: $4.23
  • Charcadet - 022

    Charcadet - 022 [MEP]

    Price: $1.61